Almost everyone who calls about their stairs describes the same feeling: the whole thing looks dated. That's a useful instinct and a bad scope. Usually only one half of the staircase is the problem, and often you can replace the stair railing without touching the stairs at all. Knowing which half changes what the job costs.
Do you need a new stair railing or new stairs?
Stand at the bottom and look at the two separately. The railing is everything you could grab: the handrail, the spindles, the newel posts and caps. The staircase is everything you walk on: the treads, the risers and the finished faces of the stringer running up the side.
Now cover one with your hand. If the stairs look fine once you stop seeing the spindles, it's a railing job. If the railing looks fine and what bothers you is worn carpet or scuffed treads, it's a staircase job. Most people find one of the two disappears as a complaint the moment they look at them apart. If those words aren't familiar, the parts of a staircase labels every one on a single photo.
Can you replace a stair railing without replacing the stairs?
Yes, and more often than people expect. The railing is the part of a staircase that dates fastest, because spindle styles move and treads don't. A house from the nineties with turned oak spindles reads as a nineties house even if the stairs underneath are in good shape.
Replacing the railing alone is also the least disruptive option in the house. There's no floor covering coming up, no structural work and nothing you need to stay off while it cures. It's priced by the lineal foot, so the length of the run is what drives the number, and an interior railing is the page that covers the scope in full.
Can you replace just the stair spindles?
Sometimes, and it's a smaller version of the same job. If your newel posts and handrail are solid and sit at the right height, sometimes only the spindles need to change, which is a contained job with a big visual payoff.
When is it time to go from carpet to hardwood stairs?
When what's wrong is underfoot. Carpet that's worn through on the nosings, treads that were never meant to be seen because they've been covered since the house was built, or a main floor that's been redone in hardwood while the stairs stayed carpeted and now stop the floor dead at the bottom step.
That's a custom staircase job, and it's how a carpet to hardwood stairs conversion is done. It brings in new hardwood treads and risers, and the finished stringer cap and fascia on the open side, fitted over the existing structure. It's a bigger scope than a railing and it's quoted after Ben has seen what's under the covering, because what's reusable varies house to house.
The other trigger is movement. A staircase that creaks underfoot or a newel post that shifts when you lean on it is telling you something the finish can't fix, and it's worth having looked at rather than covered up.
Can you replace the railing now and the stairs later?
Yes, and plenty of people do, usually because the railing is the half they can see from the living room. Doing them in stages is completely workable.
The one thing worth knowing before you split them is stain. Matching a handrail to treads is far easier when both are finished together from the same batch in the shop than when one is finished two years after the other. If you're planning to end up with both matching, say so at the first consultation even if you're only booking the railing, so the finish is recorded and can be matched later.
If the two are going in together, the shop work overlaps and it's usually better value than two separate visits. Ben quotes them as separate lines either way, so you can see both numbers and decide.
How are stair railing and staircase jobs priced?
Differently, which is exactly why the distinction matters. Railings are priced by the lineal foot, so if you can measure the run you can get an estimate emailed to you the same day without anyone visiting. Staircase work is quoted after a look, because the scope depends on what's under the existing covering.
If you're in Edmonton or the surrounding area and not sure which one you're looking at, that's a normal place to start from. Send a photo through the contact page and Ben will tell you which job it is, what he'd suggest and which of the two is actually worth doing first.
Thinking about your own stairs or railing?
Send Ben your project details, or a photo, for a no-obligation estimate.
Request a quote